Why Insureds May Win COVID-19 Claims Coverage Cases.

Media reports are that many businesses and non-profits are looking to their insurers for “business interruption” and other coverages due to the COVID-19 pandemic. At first blush, it would appear that these claims for coverage face an uphill battle based upon what might be termed clear policy language (specially manuscripted policies notwithstanding).

But it would be premature for the insurance industry to declare victory on the coverage issues. For if history is any guide, policyholders may win most of the coverage cases.

Mr prediction is based on the insurance industry’s experience in litigating various policy issues for environmental claims coverage 30 years ago. As a former Director of Environmental Claim for two insurers during the environmental claims coverage wars, I witnessed first hand how clear and otherwise unambiguous policy language did not save the insurance industry by and large from having to provide coverage for environmental claims and their massive clean-up costs. Continue reading